Best Mens Boat Shoes of 2018: Complete Reviews with Comparisons

There’s a reason why mens boat shoes are so popular. Not only do they accentuate a luxurious and high-class appeal, but they’re also comfortable and resilient against all kinds of weather. Back in the day, they were solely worn for sailing since they provide optimal traction and are easy to slip on and off. Today, however, they’re mostly a fashion statement.

Whatever your reason for wanting them, if you’re searching for the best mens boat shoes, we’ve got you covered. Here, we have five of the top pairs from reputable brands for you to consider.

Comparison Chart

Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Handsewn Boat Shoe,Rust, 7 M US
Margaritaville Men's Anchor Lace Boat Shoe, Light tan, 10 M US
Sperry Top-Sider Men's Billfish 3-Eye Boat Shoe, Dark Tan, 10 M US
Bruno Marc Men's Pitts_16 DK.BRN/DK.BRN Loafers Moccasins Boat Shoes Size 06.5
Rugged Shark Men's Classic Boat Shoes with Odor Control Technology, Navy Blue, Size 10
Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Handsewn Boat Shoe,Rust, 7 M US
Margaritaville Men's Anchor Lace Boat Shoe, Light tan, 10 M US
Sperry Top-Sider Men's Billfish 3-Eye Boat Shoe, Dark Tan, 10 M US
Bruno Marc Men's Pitts_16 DK.BRN/DK.BRN Loafers Moccasins Boat Shoes Size 06.5
Rugged Shark Men's Classic Boat Shoes with Odor Control Technology, Navy Blue, Size 10
Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Handsewn Boat Shoe,Rust, 7 M US
Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Handsewn Boat Shoe,Rust, 7 M US
Margaritaville Men's Anchor Lace Boat Shoe, Light tan, 10 M US
Margaritaville Men's Anchor Lace Boat Shoe, Light tan, 10 M US
Sperry Top-Sider Men's Billfish 3-Eye Boat Shoe, Dark Tan, 10 M US
Sperry Top-Sider Men's Billfish 3-Eye Boat Shoe, Dark Tan, 10 M US
Bruno Marc Men's Pitts_16 DK.BRN/DK.BRN Loafers Moccasins Boat Shoes Size 06.5
Bruno Marc Men's Pitts_16 DK.BRN/DK.BRN Loafers Moccasins Boat Shoes Size 06.5
Rugged Shark Men's Classic Boat Shoes with Odor Control Technology, Navy Blue, Size 10
Rugged Shark Men's Classic Boat Shoes with Odor Control Technology, Navy Blue, Size 10

Best Men’s Boat Shoes Reviews

1. Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes

Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Handsewn Boat Shoe,Rust, 7 M US

Over the years, Dockers have been a staple in many wardrobes simply because they make only high-quality clothing and footwear. The Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes is no exception, as they showcase a level of elegance that you likely won’t find from generic boat shoe manufacturers. What’s more is that this style has plenty to offer.

These shoes have quite a number of different aspects that you’re sure to appreciate, especially as they have the perfect elevated appeal that you would expect from a luxurious pair of boat shoes.

Review

The most impressive features of the Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes include:

  • Full Leather Construction

The first thing that makes the Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes a great pair of boat shoes is the fact that they are crafted using 100% leather, instead of faux leather. This means you’ll have the genuine appearance of real leather that wears well over a long period of time.

However, this also means that you’ll be responsible for taking care of the shoes and maintaining them over the years.

  • Hand-Sewn Design

Another feature that makes these shoes so luxurious is that they are hand-sewn using the most impressive craftsmanship possible. Dockers shoes are designed with elite wearers in mind, and so you can be confident that you’ll be receiving a higher quality shoe brand than if you were to purchase a pair of boat shoes from your local big box store.

  • Cushioned EVA Sole and Heel Cup

Aside from aesthetics, comfort is another important factor when it comes to finding the right pair of boat shoes. The Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes offers a cushioned EVA sole and heel cups that encapsulate your feet to help ensure you maintain a proper walking posture. Your feet will feel comfortable even after wearing these shoes for hours on end.

  • Flexible Construction

Aside from the fact that the shoes are made out of leather and will likely need to be worn in, the Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes offers a more flexible construction than what you’ll find with other boat shoes. What do we mean by this?

Similar to most leather shoes, at first, you might begin to experience some initial break-in discomfort. However, once you have worn the shoes for a day or two, you won’t have to worry about any of that.

  • Wide Widths Available

Finding the perfect sized shoe is imperative, as you’ll want to make sure that you’re investing in a wearable pair. These Dockers shoes come in a wide variety of sizes, including wide widths, to ensure you have the most comfortable pair of shoes to wear with shorts or khakis.

  • Specialized Rubber Outsoles

To enhance the level of traction that you receive when wearing these shoes in wet climates, they are designed with specialized siped rubber outsoles for optimal traction.

Pros

  • Excellent stitching
  • Wear very well after two years
  • Won’t get damaged with water exposure
  • Available in six different colors

Cons

  • The leather needs to be worked in
  • Lacing may fray

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

2. Margaritaville Men’s Anchor Lace Boat Shoes

Margaritaville Men's Anchor Lace Boat Shoe, Light tan, 10 M US

If you’re searching for a pair of boat shoes that have an impressive amount of structure and are designed for all types of outdoor wear, the Margaritaville Men’s Anchor Lace Boat Shoes are a great option.

When compared to more traditional boat shoes, this pair is seemingly designed to withstand constant wear while at the same time also giving your feet a little more structure than other pairs.

Review

The most interesting features of the Margaritaville Men’s Anchor Lace Boat Shoes include:

  • Leather and Textile Construction

With the combination of both 100% leather and textile, the shoes offer a stunning appeal that is also built to last. The vast majority of the shoe is constructed out of leather, but there is also breathable mesh on the upper side of the shoe to add a little bit of texture and additional comfort.

  • Enhanced Breathability

There’s nothing more uncomfortable than having your feet strapped into a hot pair of shoes, especially when you’re spending a lot of time outdoors during the summer. With the added textile panels on the uppers, your feet will experience a high level of air flow.

Though this is great for keeping cool on a hot summer’s day, it also means that the shoes are quite likely to allow a lot of water in if you wear them while caught in a rainstorm or out on your boat.

  • Integrated Foam Insole

Comfort is of the utmost importance, especially when it comes to shoes that you’ll likely be wearing outdoors. In comparison to traditional soles that offer little to no additional comfort, the Margaritaville Men’s Anchor Lace Boat Shoes have an integrated foam insole that gives your feet added support.

  • Added Contrast Stitching

It’s important to have a functional pair of shoes, but you’re also going to want a pair that looks great no matter what you’re wearing. We love the addition of the contrast stitching on the Margaritaville Men’s Anchor Lace Boat Shoes, as it helps to break up the color of the shoes and add a little bit of depth and dimension in all of the right areas.

  • Padded Tongue and Collar

As two other comfortable features added to the shoes, you’ll be able to reap the benefits of a padded collar and tongue. This is ideal for people who will be wearing these boat shoes in the summertime.

With that being said, one of the main downfalls of these shoes is the fact that they have branding sewn into the padded collar, which could rub against your heel and cause some chafing. Over time, you might want to consider removing the heel stitching as it may become abrasive when worn for long periods.

Pros

  • Can be laced or slipped on
  • Doesn’t leave marks on white decks
  • Perfect breathability for summer
  • A good combination of comfort and style

Cons

  • Heel stitching could cause discomfort
  • Comes in two colors only

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

3. Sperry Top-Sider Men’s Billfish Three-Eye Shoes

Sperry Top-Sider Men's Billfish 3-Eye Boat Shoe, Dark Tan, 10 M US

As another heavy-hitting brand known for their extensive collection of men’s boat shoes, the Sperry Top-Sider Men’s Billfish Three3-Eye Shoes is surely one of the more competitive pairs on this list.

Designing shoes for men of all ages, a pair of Sperry has been known to be one of the more comfortable types of boat shoes that you can get your hands on, and this pair is pretty impressive as well.

Review

The most useful features of the Sperry Top-Sider Men’s Billfish Three-Eye Shoes include:

  • 100% Leather and Air Mesh Construction

With the combination of 100% leather and air mesh, you’ll have the ideal combination of support and breathability that you would expect from a pair of shoes designed to be worn outside. They truly are a pair of multi-seasonal shoes as they’re adaptable for all seasons aside from winter.

  • Perforated Side Panels

As another feature that helps to add to the breathability of the shoes, the perforated side panels allow for a substantial amount of airflow to keep your feet cool even on the warmest days.

Even though this is a great feature to have on a particularly hot day, you’ll also find that the breathability allows a lot of water to enter the shoe, which can, in turn, result in mold to develop if you do not air your shoes out properly after being worn.

  • Molded EVA Cushion Midsole and Heel

For optimal comfort, you’ll be sure to appreciate the molded EVA cushion midsole inside of the shoe that gives your arch the support it needs if you find that you’re wearing the shoes for hours on end. The other cool feature is the molded EVA heel cup, which helps to absorb shock while walking on hard surfaces.

  • 360-degree Lacing System

As one of the most iconic aspects of Sperry’s, the Sperry Top-Sider Men’s Billfish Three-Eye Shoes offers a 360-degree lacing system that helps to achieve the most customized fit for your shoes. The laces run from the front to the back. Not only is it a useful feature, but it’s aesthetically pleasing as well.

In addition to that, it’s also important to note that the lace eyelets are constructed using rustproof materials. This means that they will stay in their best condition, even when exposed to water.

  • Non-marking shoes, Wave-siping Sole

There are two impressive aspects of the Sperry Top-Sider Men’s Billfish Three-Eye Shoes: one is that it has non-marking soles, which are ideal for wearing on white or light colored decks; and second, the soles have wave-siping, which are specifically designed to give you the best traction possible in dry and wet conditions alike.

Pros

  • Very aesthetically pleasing
  • Once broken in, can be worn without socks
  • Available in four colors
  • Comes from a trusted brand

Cons

  • Wear down sooner that some other brands
  • Stitching will stretch, exposing the sole

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

4. Bruno Marc Pitts Men’s Boat Shoes

Bruno Marc Men's Pitts_16 DK.BRN/DK.BRN Loafers Moccasins Boat Shoes Size 06.5

At first glance, the Bruno Marc Pitts Men’s Boat Shoes looks slightly different than other types of boat shoes that you’re used to seeing. This is mostly because they have a more fashion-forward appeal.

With that being said, although they are designed with sailing enthusiasts in mind, they’re more of a fashionable pair of shoes that look phenomenal when worn out for casual dinner dates or meeting up with friends for lunch.

Review

The best features of the Bruno Marc Pitts Men’s Boat Shoes include:

  • Faux Leather

One of the more agreeable features of the Bruno Marc Pitts Men’s Boat Shoes is the fact that they are made out of faux leather, which helps to limit their overall cost. If you’re looking for a trendy yet less expensive set of boat shoes, these are a great pair to take into consideration.

  • Man-made Footbed

To give you even more comfort while wearing your shoes for hours, the man-made footbed offers a little more support than your average pair of shoes. In fact, it offers the level of support similar to what you would receive when wearing a traditional loafer.

  • Non-skid Outsole

In the event that you get caught in slippery and wet weather, you’ll surely appreciate the added non-skid outsole on these shoes. These will give you a superior level of traction so you can easily move no matter where you are.

  • Versatile Wear Options

What we love the most about the Bruno Marc Pitts Men’s Boat Shoes is how adaptable they are to relatively any outfit you might be interested in wearing. As they come in over eight different colors, you can easily choose the right pair to fit into your everyday wardrobe.

Aside from that, they also have a rather enhanced appeal, which makes them a perfect partner for more business-casual looks that are laid back yet lean more towards professionalism.

Pros

  • Look fashionable
  • Comfortable for short distances
  • Comes in a variety of color options
  • A mix of classic and modern design
  • Made from Italian leather

Cons

  • Doesn’t offer much arch support

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

5. Rugged Shark Men’s Boat Shoes

Rugged Shark Men's Classic Boat Shoes with Odor Control Technology, Navy Blue, Size 10

Similar to the Bruno Marc Pitts Boat Shoes, the Rugged Shark Men’s Boat Shoes look as if they are more aesthetically pleasing than functional. However, they offer a couple of unique features that even some of the top-tier shoe manufacturers don’t.

Aside from that, they offer a design that not only strays away from the traditional look of boat shoes but accurately and effectively captures a younger audience style.

Review

The most excellent features of the Rugged Shark Men’s Boat Shoes include:

  • Odor Control Technology

As most people know, you’re quite unlikely to wear boat shoes without socks, and as such, your shoes can attract unappealing smells, especially during the summer. With the odor control technology in the Rugged Shark Men’s Boat Shoes, you can easily wear the shoes without socks and not have to worry about smells by the end of the season.

  • Genuine Leather Lining and Uppers

To give the shoes a more classic yet modernized appeal, they offer the perfect combination of textile and genuine leather lining and uppers to pull the whole look together.

  • Hidden Stitching

To help add to the longevity of the shoes, the stitching is fully hidden on the bottom so that you won’t have to worry about the sole separating from the shoe or stretching after months of repeated wear. Plus, the leather uppers help to add even more durability so you can guarantee that your shoes will last longer than other pairs on the market.

  • Anti-slip Bottom

The rubber outsole of the Rugged Shark Men’s Boat Shoes features slip-resistant traction, helping to keep you sturdy while on wet surfaces. Also, the rubber is completely non-marking, which means it’s safe to wear on light colored decks.

Pros

  • The shoes don’t scrape the back of your heels
  • Interior lining isn’t itchy
  • Truly keeps odors away
  • Comes in five attractive colors

Cons

  • Easily stained
  • Need to be worn in

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

Final Recommendation

As boat shoes are so popular, you can see that finding any old pair will be easy enough. However, you’re going to want to make sure that you find the best pair to be worn for your intended daily activities.

As you would expect, our final recommendation for the best pair of boat shoes is surely the Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes. This pair is crafted with the highest attention to detail when compared to the other selected pairs of shoes on this list. There are a few important things that set these shoes apart from the competition, including:

  • High-quality Construction

Unfortunately, the vast majority of shoe manufacturers have the tendency to focus on creating shoes that look good rather than shoes that will last over the years. However, the same cannot be said about the Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes.

When compared to other boat shoes, this pair offers the best performance. They are designed to last for years, rather than a few months. This means that you won’t have to deal with the sole breaking apart from the rest of the shoe or the stitching becoming exposed after just a few months of consistent wear.

  • Highly Resistant to Water Damage

As you would expect, boat shoes are created to give you optimal protection in wet conditions. However, there are plenty of shoes that say they’re great for water activities but experience either color fastness or significant deterioration when exposed to water, particularly salt water.

With the Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes, you won’t have to worry about the materials breaking down if they get wet on a daily basis. They are fully designed to be boat shoes, and you can guarantee they’ll last over the years.

  • Comfortable to Wear

Above all else, the Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes are designed with the everyday wearer in mind, and you can be confident that the shoes will be comfortable to wear right out of the box. They have optimal support and the perfect level of cushioning to keep your feet stable and secure, even without added insoles. With that being said, if you need specialized insoles, you can easily slip them into these shoes as well.

At the end of the day, the Dockers Men’s Vargas Leather Shoes are the top-tier pair of boat shoes that you will definitely want to get your hands on for this upcoming season.  They are easily adaptable to both casual and formal outfits alike.

Reply

CommentLuv badge